I’ll admit right off the bat; I’m a little bit of a fan-boy for the first movie. It was the little movie that could. Some bartender wrote a script that had him the toast of Hollywood and he was in line to put together a big damn movie for the Weinstein’s Miramax studio. But, unfortunately for him and for the future fans, the rise to fame made him act like such an ass there’s an entire documentary dedicated to his self destruction and the films eventual drop from Miramax and second chance as a straight to video release. But as fate had it, it still caught on. Though it took its sweet damn time.
Duffy grew up a little, got a little more humble, but emboldened by an ever expanding fan-base and after ten years, he finally got the chance to put a sequel before cameras. So here we have it on the day before Halloween and a sequel to one of the biggest cult films ever. The result: A big win for the fans. For people who didn’t like Boondock Saints to begin with? There’s nothing here for you if you weren’t on board for the original profane, violent opus to summary capital punishment. But if you’re like me and can put aside your own liberal leanings or rejection of execution under any circumstance, you can have a lot of fun here.
Like I said, I enjoyed the hell out of the BDS 1 back in the day. And while over time I can recognize many of its flaws in technical terms, weird editing and lame photography when it came to action sequences, I hoped they’d all be gone here. And for the most part they are. The violence wasn’t neutered by the MPAA and the camera doesn’t cut away every damn time somebody got shot. The general look is a lot cleaner and more, well, cinematic. With one notable exception, the way Troy shoots action kind of annoyed me. He still just shoots action sequences the same way. Saints shooting their guns impervious to enemy fire, the enemy stands and gets hit by bullets. Almost never do you actually see them in the same frame as the people they’re killing. As a film dweeb, it seems like they could have filmed the saints and the villains on totally different days.
But despite those gripes, I still had a damn good time with the movie. Troy’s distinct, and tremendously politically incorrect writing style is back in spades. Complete with a 2 minute uber-manly diatribe by David Della Rocco. I can’t wait to hear what the ‘fuck count’ was, personally. The characters, even brothers, families and best friends are constantly berating each other and calling each other morons. And it is probably the truest to life part of the movie. There’s nobody I harass or insult more than the people I love.
I was afraid the character of Eunice Bloom was just going to be a female replacement for Willem Dafoe. She still pretty much filled that role but managed to put enough of her own flair into the performance that you like her character and you don’t really care. It helps that it’s fun to see Julie Benz play against type. Not just playing some doey eyed crying victim like she usually is in movies. In Boondocks 1 we got a badass, occasionally cross dressing gay FBI agent, this time we got a sassy and tough southern agent that has a talent for dressing down her male counterparts. I’d say it’s a fair trade.
In addition, essentially filling Rocco’s role from the prior film, we have Clifton Collins as a pretty broad and silly Mexican-American street hustler that decides to join up with the brothers MacManus in their bloody quest for holy justice. His character is like I said, a little broad, but still fun to contrast against the brothers. Romeo is himself a bit of a fan-boy for the Saints and embarrasses himself repeatedly with his enthusiastic attempts to become a real member of the team. But, in all honesty, the dynamic of the two brothers simply wouldn’t work for two hours without that sidekick to help keep things light.
Surprisingly, for the premise, All Saints day ran about thirty percent longer than you’d think it would. The simple premise you’re given at the beginning of the film isn’t the only wheel that’s spinning the plot. Not to say you won’t figure out what’s really going on before they make it obvious, but you get some pretty damn cool insight into how Billy Connolly’s character became ‘Il Duche’. The flashback sequences are part of a subplot that doesn’t end up being as cool as you’d hope, but it speaks to how ambitious Troy was for upping the ante with his sophomore effort.
Overall, I think it’s worth the price of admission, maybe even if you weren’t a big fan of the first movie. It is far from perfect and doesn’t quite have the same energy the first flick had. All Saints Day is a worthy follow up for the fans and at least shows the first film wasn’t a total fluke. There’s a lot of stuff I didn’t get to touch on, in terms of flaws and strengths, but I’d rather be concise than long winded. ‘Cos you already got the point: If you liked Boondock Saints, I highly recommend strapping on your nine millimeter and heading down to the nearest Cineplex carrying Boondock Saints II: All Saints Day. If it’s not playing in your area, go to the website and demand that it be brought to your area.
iRATE it: B+